EIF on BBC Radio 3
Throughout this year’s Edinburgh International Festival, the BBC mobile recording van was parked in the lane behind the Queen’s Hall as always. However, listening to the morning concerts live on Radio 3 was no longer an option. If you wanted to enjoy this long-established summer season of chamber music as it happened, you had to get yourself to the Scottish capital’s southside to hear it in person.
What the BBC is doing with the recordings it makes only made that more essential. VoxCarnyx readers already know of the carefully-constructed programme with which Scots mezzo Beth Taylor made her EIF debut. When some of it appeared as part of Radio 3’s afternoon “Classical Live”, however, it was chopped up into unconnected chunks over several days.
The BBC is at it again in the afternoons this coming week, with the Pavel Haas Quartet’s programme of Martinu, Dvorak and Korngold spread over three days, and – even worse – music from the recital by violinist Vilde Frang and Friends split between Tuesday and Friday, entirely ignoring the premise of the recital.
Before the interval of that concert, Frang and pianist Olli Mustonen played Bela Bartok’s Violin Sonata No 1, a virtuosic half-hour-plus of sensational communication between two musicians at close quarters. It was full of intensity and expression, the violinist’s performance of it as finely-honed and precise as you might wish, and Mustonen vigorous (perhaps a little too much so at times) but also demonstrating dynamic delicacy in their dialogue. Hear it on Radio 3 on Tuesday 15th.
The context of the presentation of the work was crucial, however, showing how the composer’s dedication to collecting and transcribing folk melodies informed his own work. Mustonen’s solo performance of a selection of the Gyermekeknek piano pieces (For Children) was another highlight, but the pair also combined individually and together with Hungarian brothers Benjamin and Salamon Eredics, who also played as a duo, in a selection of arrangements of folk melodies, both by Bartok and of their own devising.
Some of their virtuosity on a range of instruments will be broadcast on the afternoon on Friday 18th, but there will be no sense of the purpose of the programme, or the conversation between traditional and classical music that flowed so intriguingly through the Queen’s Hall concert.
Another Queen’s Hall recital reaches the airwaves on Wednesday, when Steven Osborne’s contribution to the Festival’s tribute to Alfred Brendel is blessedly broadcast in full in the evening “Radio 3 in Concert” slot: Schubert spiced with Judith Weir and James MacMillan and again reviewed at the time on VoxCarnyx.
There are three Usher Hall concerts in the evenings during next week as well: Mahler’s Das klagende Lied from the BBC SSO under Sir Donald Runnicles, and soloists including Scots mezzo Catriona Morison, on Monday; then Coleridge-Taylor’s The Song of Hiawatha with tenor Nicky Spence following on Tuesday; and the opening concert of EIF 2026, Wynton Marsalis’s Symphony No 1 “All Rise”, played by the RSNO, on Thursday.
All three also featured the Edinburgh Festival Chorus, so listeners will have ample opportunity to appreciate the dedication and versatility of those singers. Like the visit to the Hub by the Aga Khan Music Programme and the Colin Currie Group’s concert to mark Steve Reich’s 90th, “All Rise” was filmed, but viewers will have to look beyond the BBC to catch those broadcasts.
Keith Bruce
(Photo: Vilde Frang & Friends by Andrew Perry)
