BBC SSO: Boccacci / Gough
BBC SSO: Boccacci / Gough
Ayr Town Hall
Ayr Town Hall presents a basic challenge for its visiting orchestras, though years of experience in dealing with its boomy acoustics have helped counter the issue. There was a sense on Wednesday, however, that the displacement of the BBC SSO from the stage to audience floor level raised old ghosts and introduced new ones. Particularly in music by Mozart and Beethoven edges were blurred and balance issues miscalculated. Visually, the forward positioning reduced the sight lines for a good proportion of the balcony audience.
That said, this was a pleasing and purposeful programme that flowed efficiently under the direction of Colombian-Italian conductor Stefano Boccacci. He is currently benefitting from the SSO connection that comes with being a Leverhulme Conducting Fellow at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland. There was an enveloping warmth in the SSO’s response to each of the performances that made up for any questionable aspects of interpretational style and detail.
He was at his most comfortable in the two folk-inspired works that opened either half of the programme. Ligeti’s Romanian Concerto proved a real sizzler. Straight out of the Bartok playbook, in which authentic Romanian folk melodies are subjected alternately to hauntingly austere stillness or ballistic rhythmically-charged frenzy, this was a performance that bristled with edgy rustic character and joyous energy. There was something demonic, too, in the wildness emanating from associate leader Kanako Ito’s virtuosic solos.
For Mozart’s Horn Concerto the limelight turned to the orchestra’s own section principal, Chris Gough, who had effectively warmed up previously with his solo offstage presence in the Ligeti. Now he was front stage, his silken tone defining a performance that coupled agile precision with genuine, unassuming musicality. Boccacci seemed content with an orchestra backing that lacked the same nimble Mozartian clarity, but the flowing lyrical qualities of the playing were well in keeping.
Vaughan Williams’ Five Variants of ‘Dives and Lazarus’, which opened the second half, proved a more relevant vehicle for the luxuriant string textures that Boccacci had advocated in the Mozart. Now the SSO strings, along with harp, were revelling in a truly pleasurable English pastoralism and warmth: five distinctive takes on a folk tune best known to some perhaps as the tune to Star of the County Down, or to churchgoers as the hymn tune Kingsfold.
Beethoven’s Fourth Symphony, given its relative brevity, sat well as a concert finale, more for its spirited energy than its accuracy of delivery. Issues arose around attack and balance, the odd insecure uptake from Boccacci resulting in rhythmic hiccups, or his contentment with the over-prominence of trumpets, a perception exaggerated by the orchestra’s floor-level positioning. Nonetheless, there were merits to this Beethoven – variously ruminative, rigorous, witty and ultimately jubilant – that overcame its shortcomings.
Ken Walton