Tag Archives: David Niemann

RSNO / Niemann / Philbert

Glasgow Royal Concert Hall

The orchestral backroom boys, so to speak, got a prominent showing with the RSNO this weekend. Mainly the percussion, but also – in Beethoven’s Eroica Symphony, the programme finale – the wider rearguard ranks of woodwind and brass. That all seemed fortuitously appropriate especially as the evening’s concerto slot, a brand new timpani showpiece by Matthew Rooke – featuring RSNO principal Paul Philbert as soloist and making his last RSNO appearance before taking up a new post in Canada – was the centrepiece. 

It was anyone’s guess how Rooke, a charismatic Oxford-born composer of Scottish and Gabonese descent whose thoughts and music constantly reflect those divergent inborn influences, would approach such a rare challenge. There are timpani concertos out there – a thunderous, rhythmically-charged and visibly entertaining one for two timpanists by Philip Glass for one. Equally there are clues to the instrument’s solo potential in such bombastic outbursts as feature in symphonies by the likes of Berlioz and Nielsen. To some extent this was an extension of the latter, Rooke opting to position his soloist on a raised platform rear-stage, but visibly attached to his exotically-equipped percussion colleagues. Philbert, besides his undoubted technical skill, is nonetheless a dynamic showman, so all eyes and ears were fixed on him for the work’s Glasgow unveiling. 

The three-movement piece, called Tamboo-Bamboo (a multi-pitched Afro-Caribbean instrument borne out of slavery’s censorial extremes), proved to be a riot of celebration and atmosphere, its opening movement driven by an almost virulent blues energy, tinged with melancholy but fired by powerful rhythmic resilience. Already the restlessness of Rooke’s musical language felt all-consuming, an eclectic menagerie touching on everything from jazz to classical rock, at its height making fleeting feisty allusions to the giddiest extremes of John Barry’s 007 soundtracks. 

Philbert’s performance – which began with simple hand claps – was dizzying to watch, whether requiring him to rotate 360 degrees to cover speedy logistics, or sourcing infinitesimal sound effects such as the surreal zoological sound world of the central Nocturne. The final Masquerade went full carnival, wild and loose-limbed, only for its intoxicating climax to be tamed by introspective reflection. 

David Niemann’s alert direction was all the more remarkable for the fact he was replacing an indisposed Anthony Parnther – we were told the German conductor had interrupted his honeymoon to be in Scotland. But the real focus of this particular performance was on the indomitable Philbert, whose show-stopping execution proved a thoroughly memorable farewell to a highly-visible and distinguished seven years tenure with the RSNO.

Panufnik’s Third Symphony, Sinfonia Sacra, written in 1964 by the exiled Polish composer to commemorate a millennium of Christianity in his native country, summoned up its own distinctive champions from within the orchestra, the initial three Visions effecting a profound sense of religious theatre. 

From the first of these – a clarion-like flourish featuring four trumpeters spread across the choir gallery – the atmosphere switched dramatically to a luscious blanket of strings introducing the mystical Vision II, the third announced by a barrage of percussion. Niemann extracted animated precision from the orchestra, especially in the more extended final Hymn where Panufnik’s musical inspiration – the ancient Polish anthem Bogurodzica – surfaced in full amid the gathering conflict and resolution.  

While Beethoven’s Third Symphony, the Eroica, might have seemed in comparison like a reassuring old friend, Niemann had other plans. As regular Eroicas go, this one was of the brisk variety, the opening hurtling off the starting blocks like a hungry whippet. But it was also super-clean and full of unexpected surprises, Niemann directing us to elements within the score that often go unnoticed, especially from the woodwind. If some of it smacked of interpretational experimentation, it was also curiously exciting. Above all, and despite some evenness across the upper string sections, Niemann’s palpable motivation bore exhilarating results.

Ken Walton

Soprano’s Valentine’s return

Korean singer Sunyoung Seo won universal acclaim in her Scottish stage debut. She talks to Keith Bruce before concert appearances with the RSNO

Of the praise that greeted Sir David McVicar’s Scottish Opera production of Puccini’s Il Trittico two years ago, a generous proportion was accorded to Korean soprano Sunyoung Seo who made her company debut in contrasting lead roles in the first two parts of the trilogy, as Giorgetta in Il tabarro and as the titular Suor Angelica.

Her absence from the comedic third opera, Gianni Schicchi, means Scotland has heard her only in a tragic context – which this week’s Valetine’s Concerts with the RSNO in Dundee, Edinburgh and Glasgow might go some way to balancing.

That depends on how you regard the Wagner’s Dich, teure Halle, from Tannhauser, and the Prelude and Liebestod from Tristan und Isolde, of course. Both are, however, celebratory pinnacles of the operatic soprano repertoire, and the latter is a work she has only recently added to her repertoire as she enters her 40s.

“I have also sung the first act of Die Walkure in concert, and Senta’s aria from The Flying Dutchman,” Sunyoung told Vox Carnyx.

“All of Wagner’s operas, with their mythological themes of salvation, their chromatic music, frequent modulations that almost feel atonal, counterpoint, and rich orchestration, have a powerful attraction. If the opportunity arises, I would love to take on other works that I have not yet performed in fully stage productions.”

Asked to identify the role that she regards most fondly, it is Dvorak’s masterpiece based on the Ondine story that she immediately names.

“Without a moment’s hesitation, it’s Rusalka. It is a work that gave me my European debut in 2011 at the Basel Theatre in Switzerland and it was also the piece that marked my professional debut in Korea in 2016. Rusalka holds a special place in my heart, like a first love.

“Given the nature of my voice, I am often cast in tragic roles. Most of the time, I play characters who either die or are involved in death. In the fall of 2023, I performed Tosca in Korea, and when I met the director, the first thing I said was, ‘I’m curious how we will kill Scarpia this time.’

“I’ve usually used a knife to kill Scarpia, but in that production, he was portrayed as a man with obsessive-compulsive disorder who covered all the furniture with thick plastic to keep it dust-free. Even the bed was covered in plastic, and I killed him by suffocating him with it, pressing it against his face.

“It’s fascinating to me that I get to live these extreme lives on stage and experience them actively. Every time I study a new piece, I find great joy in expressing and sharing the fresh, positive impressions I felt when I first encountered it.”

In those Scottish Opera roles, the soprano impressed as much in her acting as her vocal performance and she says it is her Christian faith that helps her bring a vibrancy to those dark stage moments.

“In opera, the more I identify with the situation and internalize the emotions, the more material I have to express.

“When performing the same role repeatedly, I always want to ensure that I avoid becoming mechanical and letting my emotional state become ‘numb’. For that reason, before every performance, I meditate deeply, and even on stage, I constantly pray for the presence of the Holy Spirit. I always pray that Jesus will imbue me with all the inspiration, talents, and abilities I need.”

It was the church in Korea that nurtured the young singer, long before her operatic career.

“I loved singing as a child and if guests were visiting our home or we were on family trips to the mountains or the beach during the holidays, I would often sing in front of my family. I started singing in the church choir at the age of 8.

“I was the eldest of three daughters, and my parents had no background in music, but they always encouraged and supported me. At the age of 11 I sang with the municipal children’s choir, and at 17 I began receiving professional vocal training in preparation for university entrance exams.”

Sunyoung eventually came to Europe to study at the Robert Schumann Hochschule in Dusseldorf with Professor Michaela Kramer, with whom she still works today. She continues to live in Seoul, however, and maintains strong links with Korea’s National University of the Arts where she completed her undergraduate studies.

“I began my teaching career at my alma mater at the relatively young age of 35. In my classes with students, I often feel less like I am teaching them and more like I am sharing what I’ve learned, and in many cases, I feel that I learn from them as well.

“The university boasts a high success rate in international competitions and with prestigious opera houses and orchestras around the world. Our school is a specialized arts institution consisting of six colleges: music, dance, fine arts, theatre, film, and traditional arts. Students are encouraged to experience classes from other departments, allowing many singers to gain valuable acting experience in the theatre department.”

Balancing her international career with teaching responsibilities at home means that opportunities to hear her voice in Europe can be rare. This year much of her work is in Korea and Japan, including a concert Rusalka, Mahler Symphonies No 4 and 2, a production of Britten’s The Turn of the Screw and an appearance in Tokyo as part of a celebration of 60 years of Korea-Japan diplomatic relations.

Look out for her return in 2026 though, when she makes her Netherlands debut as Suor Angelica, and it is whispered, may well be seen again in a Scottish Opera production.

The RSNO’s Valentine’s Concert, which follows Wagner with Tchaikovsky’s Pathétique Symphony, is at Dundee’s Caird Hall on February 13, Edinburgh’s Usher Hall on February 14 and Glasgow Royal Concert Hall on February 15, conducted by David Niemann.

RSNO: Viennese Gala

Perth Concert Hall

The challenge with any traditional orchestral Viennese Gala is to make it more than just a routine January roll out. There’s not much you can do with the music itself – it will always be a core diet of Strauss family favourites, otherwise what’s the point? So it boils down to a presentation and performance format that will give the evening the necessary zing factor. This Perth performance by the RSNO was the first in a line of repeat presentations heading around parts of Scotland till next weekend.

By the time it reaches Saturday’s final destination in Greenock I suspect this particular Viennese Gala will be as svelte as any Vienna Philharmonic New Year’s Day broadcast, but with more of a homely flavour as befits an audience probably reared on the couthy fireside charm of The White Heather Club. 

Thanks then to Scots broadcaster and versatile tenor Jamie MacDougall for doing not so much his Andy Stewart, but a creditable Bill McCue in peppering this tinselly sequence of Strauss perennials with an engaging mix of song and patter.

This was welcome in periodically whisking us away from the stylised 19th century Vienna populism so monopolised by the Strauss family business. MacDougall unleashed his inner John McCormack in the glorious sentimentalism that characterises such schmalzy numbers as pre-World War II German film composer Werner Richard Heymann’s Ein blonder Traum, Rudolf Sieczyński’s one-hit wonder, Vienna, City of My Dreams, or one actually made famous by McCormack, Charles Marshall’s I Hear You Calling Me.

The only detraction from these was a seemingly low-set amplification level, which left MacDougall partially unheard in the earlier songs. Correction made all the difference in the second half, making such further gems as Juventino Rosas’ The Loveliest Night of the Year and the more melancholy hue of Paolo Tosti’s L’ultima Canzona easy listening in every sense.

If MacDougall livened up the continuity, the conductor David Niemann – in his RSNO debut – responded with equally lithesome musical direction, evident straight off in the opening Overture from Johann Strauss II’s popular opera Die Fledermaus. For the most part, he garnered a rich response from the orchestra, at their best in the same composer’s febrile Thunder and Lightning Waltz, the more reserved ebullience of the Emperor Waltz, and in a quirky novelty piece, Künstler-Quadrille, that pieces together snatches of themes by other composers, almost too many to count.

Things weren’t so refined in the famous Blue Danube, where Niemann’s excessive temporal deliberations seemed to fox the players. Among the non-Strauss works, the same issue imbued Delibes’ Pizzicato Polka with a few stray plucks, unlike the hearty confidence exhibited in the foregoing Brahms Hungarian Dance. 

Other Strausses featured: brother Josef’s Ohne Sorgen! Polka, with its additionally notated guffaws from the players; and Johann Strauss I’s rousing Radetzky March as a programmed encore that very nearly didn’t happen. Niemann lingered overlong on his return to the stage, resulting in the audience applause fading prematurely. He made it, just in time to make it happen. 

Having served Dunfermline and Langholm since, and with Inverness and Musselburgh to come this week en route to Greenock, this enjoyable programme will probably be running like clockwork now.

Ken Walton

Further performances at Eden Court, Inverness (12 Jan), The Brunton Theatre, Musselburgh (13 Jan) and Beacon Arts Centre, Greenock (14 Jan)